Believing God Exists Isn’t Enough for Prayer


I’ve spent so much time worrying about whether or not God exists that I overlooked a more important question. If I believe that God exists, do I believe in a God that I would approach in prayer?

Another way to ask that would be: If I believe in God, do I believe in a loving, merciful God who wants nothing more than for me to pray? Or do I let my imagination create images of an angry, violent, and petty God who is waiting for me to finally mess up enough to justify banishing me from his presence forever?

That latter image haunted my prayers for years. Whenever I struggled to pray, I told myself, “Well, this is it. You’ve finally done it. God has finally turned away from you, and there’s no hope. Prayer may work for other people, but it won’t work for you.”

By imagining a God who could take me or leave me, waiting to strike me down, or to cast me away at the slightest infraction, I made it extremely hard to pray. If I can’t imagine God liking me, let alone loving me and seeing me with compassion and mercy, it’s awfully hard to begin to pray.

Perhaps we struggle to reconcile the God of Hebrew Bible who throws down thunder, hail stones, and fire from the heavens. Perhaps we can’t reconcile those stories with the proclamations of the Psalms:

The LORD is full of compassion and mercy, slow to anger and of great kindness.
Psalm 103:8

I don’t know how to create a theological system that seamlessly accounts for these stories and comfortably fits them in with the many verses in the Psalms and prophets where God is described as merciful, compassionate, full of love, and loving for his people like a jilted lover.

Here’s what I do know: the people who seek God in prayer have found more love, mercy, and compassion than they ever would have guessed. When the mystics write about the presence of God, there is awe and even a bit of fear at times, but God is love, compassion and mercy.

The people who have dedicated their lives to prayer overwhelming reveal that the God we seek is the kind of God we would want to seek.

That isn’t to say that our faults or sins aren’t a big deal. Anyone who believes in the cross and resurrection would recognize that these are important problems that God himself has set out to resolve. The point for me is not minimizing my faults, it’s seeing the largeness of God’s love, mercy, and compassion.

My mistake wasn’t underestimating the seriousness of sin; it was underestimating how deeply God loves us.

Over and over again in the Gospels, I see Jesus telling people that God is more loving and merciful than they expect, that more people are welcome than they suspect, and that the supposed barriers between people and God are actually not holding anyone back.

Perhaps the greatest struggle for Christians today isn’t believing God exists, it’s believing that God is merciful.

We do ourselves no good if we believe in a God that we fear, a God we dare not approach, or a God who is so terrible that we fail to open our deepest fears and pains to him.

In the vast reserves of God’s love and mercy, there is room for us to come as we are and to seek healing and restoration. The greatest obstacle to God’s mercy is believing that it exists and applies even to you and to me.


Read more about the basics of contemplative prayer and Christian spirituality in my latest book:

Flee, Be Silent, Pray: An Anxious Evangelical Finds Peace with God through Contemplative Prayer

On sale for $2.99

Amazon Kindle | Amazon print | Kobo | B&N


6 thoughts on “Believing God Exists Isn’t Enough for Prayer

  1. Yes, I can really relate to this! You’ve put it so well. Coming from a strict Reformed tradition, and rather harsh discipline and expectations from my parents, the seriousness of my sin and need for repentance has been impressed on me my whole life, so much so that I had become very fearful and full of shame. I learned to close myself up and go through the motions of being a Christian. As a young child I did love God, and tried to pray everyday – but I remember when I didn’t pray for a day or a few, I’d come to him afraid and so ashamed that I could barely bring myself to do it. He didn’t really like me, I thought, how could he? It only got worse as I grew up. Had I been able to see God’s mercy, I would have clung to him like I do now. Coming back to him would have been a relief if I believed in his desire for me! I can begin to love him with all my heart when I seek him and find that he just wants me, even as I am – simple as that.


    1. That is very close to my experience of God as well. I didn’t realize just how much I’d internalized the notion that God only accepted me because of a spiritual transaction–substitutionary atonement. When I began to see God as a deliverer and the conquerer of evil seeking out his lost people, I started to understand the verses in the Bible about his love and mercy.


      1. Yes, I think I understand what you’re saying. God has always loved us without condition and would always accept us – but we didn’t accept him because we were blind to him and lost in our ways. It was because God wanted to restore us to himself at any cost that Jesus sacrificed himself – to show us the extent of his love and mercy and to bring us back. God doesn’t just love us only now that our sins have been paid for, only now that we turn from sin. He always longs for us.

        About reconciling the passages about God’s unfailing mercy with the one about his fury and apparent harshness with the disobedient people, I’ve struggled with the incongruity. I have found Peter Enn’s book, The Bible Tells Me So, to be rather enlightening on this subject. Though it doesn’t, of course, provide clear-cut reasons for the various understandings of God, it got me thinking about why Old Testament authors wrote about God in such different ways. Maybe you’ve read it.


        1. “to show us the extent of his love and mercy and to bring us back.” I would add to that, like you said, to conquor the power of sin in us, to free us from its grip.


  2. Yes! Our relationship with God in the key part, so if our image of God doesn’t let us relate to God then there is something wrong with the image we are using. When the image we use is based in God’s love and mercy, then God is always approachable, we can expect than God will always treat us with loving-kindness and tenderness. That image we hold is key to our relationship.


Comments are closed.